The Critical Line - Volume 23

Reading time: 2 mins

Dan Mayoh serves up a dicey problem for Volume 23 of the Critical Line. Plus, Oliver shares the solution to Volume 22 and its winner - who stood out by submitting an animated solution to the problem!

The problem this month is not of my own creation. It is based on a question that as I understand it originally appeared in the Online Math Olympiad. I quite like it though because there are a number of different ways of arriving at the solution, most of which should be familiar to those trained in the actuarial sciences, and it doesn’t require a computer.

At exactly 12:00 noon, you begin a game with 6 regular 6-sided dice. Nothing much happens for the first 60 seconds. At exactly 12:01, you instantly roll all 6 dice. Any dice with a value of 4, 5 or 6 are considered ‘locked’ and set aside, not to be rolled again. Any remaining dice will be re-rolled after waiting 1 minute. At exactly 12:02, you instantly roll the remaining dice. This process is repeated, where dice with a value of 4, 5 or 6 are locked and set aside, and remaining dice re-rolled after 1 minute, until eventually all 6 dice are locked.

What is the expected value of the time at which the final dice becomes locked? Exact answers only to the relevant fraction of a second please!

For bonus marks (but no additional book voucher), what is the expected value if instead of 4, 5 or 6, the dice require a value of only 5 or 6 to become locked?

For your chance to win a $50 book voucher, send your solutions to


Solution to Critical Line 22 – by Oliver Chambers

We had 13 submissions this month and 7 correct entries. Congratulations to Rob Deutsch, Tatiana Potemina, Mike Fowlds, Kelvin Duong, Ean Chan, Will Gardner and Andrew Parker.

This month’s winner is Ean Chan – who not only gave a correct solution but also provided a program to test different strategies.

The strategy is to put the bug into a race with the spiders, and then it is guaranteed that the spiders will catch the bug because they are faster. One way to do this is as follows – as illustrated below have one spider follow the black path . We can keep the bug on this circuit by having the other two spiders guard the red edges ( and ). They move between the vertices at half speed and meet the first spider as it passes either vertex.


CPD Actuaries Institute Members can claim two CPD points for every hour of reading articles on Actuaries Digital.

About the author

Dan Mayoh

Dan Mayoh is the founder and Managing Director of Fintega, a specialised financial modelling consultancy.  Dan is also a lead question designer for the ModelOff Financial Modeling World Championships.

Comment on the article (Be kind)


No Comments

Also this month